SimpleLogin vs Addy: Where Does ProxiedMail Stand?
Email alias services used to be compared mostly by counting aliases, domains and mailboxes. Those numbers still matter, but they no longer tell the whole story.
Today, the more important questions are:
- Who controls the service?
- Can you trust its development direction?
- Can you leave without losing your aliases?
- Will you be paying a subscription indefinitely?
- Is the product only for anonymous sign-ups, or can it become part of your real email infrastructure?
SimpleLogin, Addy and ProxiedMail answer these questions differently. ForwardMX is often included in the same conversation, but it serves a somewhat different audience.
Disclosure: this comparison is written by ProxiedMail. We obviously have a point of view, so we link to competitors' own documentation and distinguish documented facts from our opinion. Prices and limits were checked on 15 November 2026 and may change.
SimpleLogin: a strong product with a more complicated trust story
SimpleLogin remains one of the most capable email alias services on the market. Its Premium plan currently provides unlimited aliases, unlimited custom domains, anonymous replies, new outbound conversations, PGP encryption and unlimited destination mailboxes. It is also open source and can be self-hosted.
At the time of writing, SimpleLogin Premium costs $36 per year or $4 per month.
The concern is no longer primarily SimpleLogin's feature set. It is its ownership and future direction.
SimpleLogin joined Proton in 2022 and now powers the aliases available through Proton Pass. It is therefore difficult to evaluate SimpleLogin's future independently of Proton's engineering and leadership decisions.
That became more relevant in October 2026, when 404 Media reported on Proton's internal AI push. According to the report, Proton CEO Andy Yen dismissed an employee's suggestion to allow additional time for penetration testing and told engineers to stop "lovingly handcrafting" code and use AI more.
For an ordinary productivity application, that might be only an internal management controversy. For a company selling private email, encrypted communication and password management, engineering culture is part of the trust model.
This reporting does not prove that SimpleLogin is insecure. No SimpleLogin breach was established. Proton later published a detailed explanation stating that every code change still requires human approval, security scanning remains mandatory, and AI-generated code cannot bypass its normal review process. Proton's security response deserves to be read alongside the original report.
SimpleLogin also remains open source and self-hostable. That gives technically capable users an escape route that a closed-source service cannot provide.
Our conclusion is more nuanced than "SimpleLogin is bad":
SimpleLogin is technically strong, but users must decide whether they remain comfortable with Proton's leadership and development direction.
Addy: focused, transparent and pleasantly boring
Addy takes a cleaner and more focused approach. It provides aliases, anonymous replies, custom domains, browser extensions, mobile apps, API access and webhooks without trying to become an entire privacy ecosystem.
It is open source and can be self-hosted. Addy also describes itself as independently run and free of venture-capital funding. For users concerned about vendor control, those are meaningful advantages.
Addy's current pricing is straightforward:
- Free: unlimited username-based aliases, one recipient and 10 MB of monthly forwarding bandwidth.
- Lite: $1 per month when billed annually, one custom domain, five recipients and 100 MB of monthly bandwidth.
- Pro: $3 per month when billed annually, 20 custom domains, 30 recipients and unlimited bandwidth.
Addy's weakness is not that it is expensive. It is one of the most affordable serious alias products available. The tradeoff is that the relationship remains subscription-based.
There is no lifetime plan. When a subscription ends, paid features such as custom domains, additional usernames and additional recipients are deactivated. Addy says they can be restored by resubscribing within its documented recovery period.
For many customers, that is perfectly reasonable. Addy is inexpensive, open source and focused on doing one job well. Someone building a permanent email identity, however, may not want another subscription that must be maintained indefinitely.
Addy is probably the cleanest choice for users who prioritize open source, self-hosting and a low recurring price.
Where ProxiedMail stands
ProxiedMail occupies a somewhat different position. It combines personal email masking with custom-domain forwarding and developer-oriented email infrastructure.
Depending on the selected plan, ProxiedMail provides:
- Unlimited proxy email addresses
- Unlimited custom domains
- Replies through a proxy address
- New outbound conversations from a proxy address
- Multiple real destination addresses
- API and webhook support
- Catch-all addresses
- AI-powered email bots
- A one-time Forever plan
You can review the current details on the ProxiedMail pricing page.
The one-time plan is the clearest difference in business model. Addy and SimpleLogin ask customers to maintain a subscription. ProxiedMail offers the option to pay once for continuing access.
That does not automatically make ProxiedMail better. Addy and SimpleLogin have mature open-source ecosystems and can be self-hosted. ProxiedMail currently competes through its hosted service, broader automation features and payment model, not through self-hostability.
ProxiedMail makes the most sense for someone who needs more than a browser alias generator:
- You manage several custom domains.
- You want aliases that can survive a change from Gmail to Proton Mail, Fastmail or another inbox provider.
- You need real two-way communication rather than receive-only forwarding.
- You want to create integrations through an API or trigger a webhook when an email arrives.
- You want to connect an address to an AI email bot or another automated workflow.
- You prefer a one-time purchase to a permanent subscription.
ProxiedMail is the strongest fit when aliases are becoming email infrastructure rather than merely disposable addresses for website sign-ups.
What about ForwardMX?
ForwardMX is worth considering, but it is not a direct replacement for SimpleLogin or Addy. It is primarily a custom-domain forwarding service for businesses, teams and people managing domain portfolios.
It does several things well: catch-all routing, SMTP sending, team access, forwarding to multiple recipients and API-based domain management.
Its limitations are also fairly clear.
It is not a ready-made privacy alias service
ForwardMX requires a domain you control and access to its DNS records. It does not give a new user a shared-domain address for quickly masking an identity during a website sign-up.
Sending also relies on SMTP configuration. For example, its own Gmail instructions require users to add an address manually, configure the ForwardMX SMTP server, and manage separate SMTP credentials. That is suitable for domain email, but it is a different experience from replying through a privacy alias.
Its standard plans are capped
According to ForwardMX pricing, its current plans include:
- Personal: one domain, 100 forwarders and 500 forwarded messages per day.
- Starter: up to 30 domains, 100 forwarders per domain and 2,000 forwarded messages per day per domain.
- Pro: up to 125 domains, 500 forwarders per domain and 4,000 forwarded messages per day per domain.
- Business: up to 250 domains, 1,000 forwarders per domain and 10,000 forwarded messages per day per domain.
There is no free or lifetime plan. The Personal plan costs $30 per year, while the multi-domain Starter plan begins at $72 per year when billed annually.
Some operational controls are outside the user's hands
ForwardMX states that its spam filters cannot be disabled. This protects the reputation of its forwarding infrastructure, but it also means customers cannot turn filtering off if it produces a false positive.
Its pricing FAQ says full email contents are not logged, while troubleshooting logs containing information such as sender addresses and subject lines are deleted after seven days.
The ForwardMX email terms also say that mail may be relayed through servers in multiple jurisdictions, including the United States. Its sending-infrastructure documentation describes fallback delivery through external providers when its primary relays receive a rejection.
Finally, its acceptable use policy prohibits mailing lists and newsletters. It also says excessive catch-all use from a single source can lead to immediate termination.
None of this makes ForwardMX a bad service. It makes it a specialized one:
ForwardMX is useful domain-routing infrastructure, but it is less compelling as a personal privacy and identity-protection layer.
Side-by-side summary
| Service | Best fit | Open source / self-hosted | Custom domains | Start new emails | Lifetime option |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SimpleLogin | Full-featured privacy aliasing and Proton users | Yes | Unlimited on Premium | Yes | No |
| Addy | Independent, inexpensive privacy aliasing | Yes | 1 on Lite, 20 on Pro | Yes on paid plans | No |
| ProxiedMail | Aliases, custom domains and programmable email workflows | No | Unlimited on paid plans | Yes | Yes |
| ForwardMX | Teams and portfolios of custom domains | No | Plan-dependent | Yes, through SMTP | No |
The short answer
Choose SimpleLogin if you want a polished, open-source alias platform and remain comfortable with Proton's ownership and engineering direction.
Choose Addy if you want a focused, inexpensive and self-hostable alias service and do not mind paying a recurring fee.
Choose ForwardMX if your primary problem is routing mail across a portfolio of business domains rather than hiding your personal identity.
Choose ProxiedMail if you want aliases, unlimited custom domains, two-way communication, API and webhook automation, and a one-time payment option in the same service.
The real differentiator is not simply how many aliases each product offers. It is whether you want an alias utility, a domain-forwarding service, or a permanent programmable layer between your identity and your inbox.
Create a free ProxiedMail account or review all available plans.


